Opinion

KYAMBOGO UNIVERSITY LECTURER WRITTES AN OPEN LETTER TO MR. FRANK GASHUMBA: ON MIRACLES, THE CHURCH, AND THE RESPONSIBILITY OF PUBLIC SPEECH

Ad

 

Dear Mr. Frank Gashumba,

Having addressed the concerns surrounding your criticism of pastors and miracles, I would now like to address you personally and respectfully.

First and foremost, I write to you in my capacity as a pastor and church leader in Uganda. I want to make it clear that I am not writing out of anger, resentment, or a desire to engage in a public confrontation. Rather, I am writing out of a sincere concern for the truth of God’s Word, the integrity of the Church, and the responsibility that comes with speaking publicly about matters of faith.

I am among the pastors who firmly believe in a miracle-working God—a God who heals, delivers, saves, speaks to His people, and exercises sovereign authority over all creation. I believe that God can communicate with His people through dreams, visions, prophecy, words of knowledge, wisdom, and, above all, His revealed Word.

The Bible declares in Hebrews 13:8 that “Jesus Christ is the same yesterday, and today, and forever.” I therefore see no biblical justification for dismissing God’s miraculous power simply because some people may have misrepresented it or abused the faith of unsuspecting believers.

Dr. Mukwana

Mr. Gashumba, there are three important matters I would like you to consider. I believe that reflecting on them sincerely will help us all approach this subject with greater wisdom, humility, and discernment.

  1. Before Criticising the Church, Let Us Examine the Basis of Our Criticism

Your criticism of pastors and miracles can be understood in at least three possible ways.

First, it may arise from a misunderstanding of what the Bible teaches about God, miracles, and the work of the Holy Spirit. Second, it may be motivated by a genuine concern about false prophets, deceptive ministers, and the exploitation of vulnerable believers. Third, it may be an attempt to attract public attention or gain popularity.

I do not claim to know your heart, and I will not presume to judge your motives. Only God knows the intentions of every human heart. However, I believe these are possibilities worth examining honestly.

The Bible cautions us in Proverbs 18:13 that answering a matter before hearing it fully is folly and shame. Similarly, 1 Thessalonians 5:21 instructs believers to “test everything; hold fast what is good” (ESV).

Therefore, if your intention is to defend the public against religious exploitation, I acknowledge that concern as legitimate. False prophets, manipulative religious leaders, and those who use the name of God to enrich themselves or abuse vulnerable people must not be shielded from accountability.

However, if your criticism is based on the assumption that miracles are impossible, that every pastor who speaks about miracles is a fraud, or that the failures of some ministers invalidate the work of God, then I respectfully disagree with you.

We must distinguish between the abuse of God’s name and the genuine work of God. The existence of counterfeit money does not mean genuine money does not exist. In the same way, the existence of false ministers does not establish that all ministers are false or that God has ceased to work miracles.

  1. God Is Sovereign; No Pastor Is the Source of Miracles

Mr. Gashumba, I would like you to understand one fundamental biblical truth: God is sovereign, and no human being can command Him as though He were a machine programmed to fulfil our wishes.

Pastors do not possess independent supernatural power. No genuine minister of God should claim to be the ultimate source of healing, deliverance, or miracles. God alone is the source of divine power, and any genuine ministry operates by His grace and according to His will.

In Exodus 15:26, God reveals Himself as the Lord who heals. In 1 Corinthians 12:4–11, the apostle Paul teaches that spiritual gifts are distributed by the Holy Spirit according to His will. Furthermore, Romans 9:15 reminds us of God’s sovereign mercy: “I will have mercy on whom I have mercy.”

Even Jesus Christ, in the Garden of Gethsemane, prayed in Luke 22:42, “Nevertheless not my will, but thine, be done.”

These Scriptures teach us that prayer is not a mechanism for controlling God. Neither miracles nor healing should be presented as commodities that a minister can manufacture at will. We pray in faith, but we also submit to God’s wisdom, authority, and sovereignty.

God may heal through prayer, medicine, medical professionals, or means we do not fully understand. He may answer our prayers in ways we did not anticipate, and there are times when the healing we seek does not occur as we hoped. Such realities should lead us to humility rather than to simplistic conclusions about God’s existence or the sincerity of every person who prays.

James 5:14–16 encourages the sick to call upon the elders of the Church to pray for them, while acknowledging the importance of faith and prayer. It does not teach that pastors possess autonomous healing power.

Therefore, when someone testifies to a miracle, the proper response is neither automatic acceptance nor automatic ridicule. We should examine the testimony honestly, seek evidence where appropriate, and remain humble before God.

Let us hold ministers accountable for their claims without arrogantly placing limits on what God can do.

  1. Exposing False Ministers Requires Discernment, Not Recklessness

If your intention is to expose false prophets and pastors who exploit the public, then I urge you to pursue that cause with wisdom, fairness, and biblical discernment.

In Matthew 13:24–30, Jesus tells the parable of the wheat and the weeds. When the servants asked whether they should pull out the weeds, the master instructed them to allow both to grow until the harvest, lest the wheat be uprooted along with the weeds.

The lesson is not that false teaching should never be challenged. Scripture clearly calls believers to discernment and correction. Rather, the parable warns us against acting rashly and destroying what is good while attempting to remove what is bad.

Indeed, Jesus also warned in Matthew 7:15 that false prophets come in sheep’s clothing but inwardly are ravenous wolves. In 1 John 4:1, believers are instructed not to believe every spirit but to test the spirits. And in Titus 1:9–11, church leaders are instructed to uphold sound doctrine and correct those who contradict it.

Consequently, Christians have a responsibility to confront deception. However, we must do so on the basis of truth, credible evidence, and sound judgment—not insults, sweeping generalisations, or public humiliation.

Mr. Gashumba, I must also point out that some religious deceptions can be deeply entrenched and difficult to expose. People may employ elaborate schemes, manipulate testimonies, stage events, or use spiritual language to convince their followers that their activities have divine approval. This is precisely why discernment, evidence, and accountability are essential.

We should neither attribute every unusual event to God nor assume that every unusual event is demonic. We must examine matters carefully and avoid making accusations we cannot substantiate.

Please understand that I am not warning you against legitimate scrutiny of religious leaders. On the contrary, I support the exposure of proven wrongdoing. I am urging you to ensure that your criticism is accurate, proportionate, and responsible as well as respectful.

The answer to religious deception is not reckless condemnation; it is truth, discernment, accountability, and justice.

  1. Christian Faith Must Be Reflected in Our Speech and Conduct

Finally, Mr. Gashumba, I would like to address the manner in which criticism is expressed.

I understand that you are a public figure, and public figures have the right to question religious institutions and challenge claims they believe to be false. No pastor should be above scrutiny, and no church leader should demand immunity from criticism.

Nevertheless, the right to criticise does not remove the responsibility to speak with dignity, fairness, and restraint.

Your wife reportedly stated, in response to a woman pastor in Kampala, that you fear God and pray every day. If that is indeed an accurate representation of your spiritual life, then I respectfully encourage you to let your public conduct reflect the faith you profess.

The Bible says in 1 John 4:7–8 that we should love one another, because love is from God, and whoever does not love does not know God, for God is love. Ephesians 4:29 further instructs us not to let corrupt communication proceed from our mouths, but to speak what is good for building others up.

Likewise, James 1:19 reminds us to be quick to hear, slow to speak, and slow to anger. And Colossians 4:6 teaches that our speech should always be gracious.

Christianity does not forbid correction; it teaches us how to correct. We can challenge falsehood without humiliating people. We can disagree strongly without becoming abusive. We can demand accountability without abandoning civility.

If the words you directed at a pastor were insulting or degrading, then I respectfully submit that such language was inappropriate, regardless of whether your underlying concerns were justified. A valid argument loses much of its moral force when it is delivered through personal insults.

The Bible’s instruction in Galatians 6:1 is particularly relevant: those who are caught in wrongdoing should be restored in a spirit of gentleness, while each person remains mindful of their own vulnerability to error.

Mr. Gashumba, my Christian advice is therefore straightforward: I respectfully encourage you to return to the same television platform, clarify your position, and publicly apologise to the pastor you insulted if your words were indeed degrading. You can maintain your position on any substantive issue while acknowledging that the manner in which you expressed it was wrong.

Such an apology would not mean abandoning your right to question religious leaders. Rather, it would demonstrate maturity, humility, and a willingness to accept responsibility for one’s words. It would also help the public distinguish between legitimate criticism of religious misconduct and disrespect towards people.

If you truly fear God and seek to live according to His Word, then this is an opportunity to demonstrate that faith through your actions, not merely through your declarations.

My Final Appeal to You

Mr. Gashumba, Uganda needs honest public debate, responsible religious leadership, and citizens who are willing to challenge wrongdoing wherever it occurs. We need pastors who do not exploit their congregations, public figures who do not mislead their audiences, and citizens who can disagree without descending into insults and hostility.

Let us reject false prophets without rejecting the truth of God’s Word. Let us expose religious exploitation without ridiculing sincere believers. Let us defend the vulnerable without making reckless accusations. Above all, let us speak the truth in love, as instructed in Ephesians 4:15.

My intention is not to fight you, silence you, or deny you the freedom to express your views. It is to encourage you to exercise that freedom responsibly, with due regard for truth, fairness, and the dignity of others.

May God grant you wisdom, discernment, humility, and the courage to acknowledge when a correction is necessary. May He also grant us, as pastors and church leaders, the integrity to live according to the very Scriptures we preach to others.

May the Lord bless you, guide you, and give us all the grace to speak and act in ways that honour Him.

For God and My Country — Uganda!

Rev. Dr. Nicholas Isaack Mukwana

About the author;

He is an associate Pastor at WE CONNECT CHURCH, JINJA and Lecturer English language, Literature and Communication Skills at Kyambogo University