Opinion

PART EIGHT: CAN SOMEONE CLAIM TO BE BORN AGAIN WHILE CONTINUING TO LIVE IN REBELLION AGAINST GOD?

Ad

By Rev. Dr. Samuel Elijah Kibirige

Christian Minister, Scholar and Author
Good Shepherd Community Ministries (GOSHEM)

Throughout this series, we have been examining a question of profound spiritual importance:
“Do we, as human beings, attract divine punishment for rebellion if we refuse to accept Jesus Christ as our personal Saviour?”
So far, much of our discussion has concerned those who have not accepted Jesus Christ.
However, there is another question we must not avoid:
What about those who publicly declare that they have accepted Jesus Christ but continue deliberately living in ways that contradict His teachings?
Can a person genuinely claim to be Born Again while persistently practising dishonesty, exploitation, hatred, injustice or other forms of deliberate disobedience?
This question is especially important because the Gospel does not merely call unbelievers to repentance.
It also calls professing Christians to examine their lives.

1. BEING BORN AGAIN IS MORE THAN A RELIGIOUS DECLARATION
In John 3:3-7, Jesus taught Nicodemus about the necessity of the new birth.
The new birth is the regenerating work of the Holy Spirit.
It is not simply a change of religious vocabulary, church membership or public identity.
Second Corinthians 5:17 declares that anyone who is in Christ is a new creation.
This transformation should affect a person’s values, conduct, relationships and priorities.
A person may publicly declare, “I am Born Again,” yet the declaration itself does not establish that genuine spiritual regeneration has occurred.
Jesus warned in Matthew 7:21 that not everyone who calls Him Lord will enter the kingdom of heaven.
A Christian profession is important, but it must not be confused with the reality of a transformed relationship with God.

2. WHAT DOES JESUS TEACH ABOUT OBEDIENCE?
Jesus connected genuine discipleship with obedience.
In John 14:15, He declared:
“If ye love me, keep my commandments.” John 14:15 (KJV)
Luke 6:46 records Jesus asking why people call Him Lord while failing to do what He says.
These statements challenge the idea that accepting Christ has no implications for daily conduct.
A genuine relationship with Jesus Christ should produce a growing desire to obey His Word.
This does not mean that Christians become perfect immediately after conversion.
It means that obedience becomes an essential direction of their lives.
The grace that saves us also calls us to live under the lordship of Jesus Christ.

3. DOES SALVATION BY GRACE GIVE CHRISTIANS PERMISSION TO CONTINUE IN SIN?
No.
Romans 6:1-2 directly challenges the suggestion that believers should continue in sin because grace is available.
The Apostle Paul rejects that reasoning.
Titus 2:11-12 teaches that God’s grace trains believers to reject ungodliness and live upright lives.
Grace is not a licence for deliberate wrongdoing.
It is God’s undeserved favour that brings salvation and calls believers into a new way of life.
Therefore, a person should not use the statement “I am saved by grace” to justify exploitation, immorality, dishonesty or persistent disobedience.
Grace is not permission to rebel against God. It is the foundation of a transformed life.

4. WHAT IS THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN STRUGGLING WITH SIN AND LIVING IN DELIBERATE REBELLION?
This distinction is extremely important.
Christians continue to experience temptation and may fall into sin.
First John 1:8 warns against claiming to be without sin.
First John 1:9 teaches that God is faithful to forgive those who confess their sins.
However, there is a difference between a believer who falls, recognises wrongdoing, repents and seeks restoration, and a person who deliberately continues in sin while rejecting correction.
The first demonstrates a willingness to return to God.
The second displays a dangerous attitude toward God’s authority.
Hebrews 10:26-29 contains a serious warning about wilful sin and contempt for God’s gracious provision.
We should not use that passage to declare that every struggling Christian has lost salvation.
Its warning must be read carefully in its context.
Nevertheless, Scripture does not treat persistent, unrepentant rebellion as spiritually harmless.
A Christian who struggles with sin needs repentance and restoration. A person who deliberately celebrates sin while rejecting God’s correction needs to take the warning of Scripture seriously.

5. WHAT EVIDENCE SHOULD FOLLOW GENUINE CONVERSION?
Jesus taught that people are recognised by their fruits (Matthew 7:16-20).
Galatians 5:22-23 identifies the fruit of the Spirit as love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, gentleness and self-control.
James 2:17 teaches that faith without works is dead.
These passages remind us that genuine faith should increasingly become visible in conduct.
A transformed life should demonstrate honesty in business, faithfulness in relationships, compassion toward the vulnerable, humility in leadership and integrity in the use of money.
Such qualities do not purchase salvation.
They are evidence of the transforming work of God’s grace.
The fruit of the Spirit is a stronger witness to spiritual maturity than religious titles, public declarations or impressive spiritual performances.

6. CAN A PASTOR OR CHURCH LEADER LIVE IN REBELLION?
Yes.
Religious leadership does not place a person above the moral demands of Scripture.
A pastor may preach about righteousness while privately practising dishonesty.
A bishop may speak about holiness while abusing authority.
An apostle may proclaim generosity while exploiting those entrusted to his care.
Such conduct cannot be justified merely by appealing to a spiritual title or religious calling.
First Peter 5:2-3 instructs church leaders to shepherd God’s people without exploiting or dominating them.
First Timothy 3:1-7 sets out moral qualifications for church oversight.
James 3:1 warns that teachers will face stricter judgment.
These passages demonstrate that spiritual leadership carries responsibility rather than immunity from accountability.
No Christian leader should demand obedience to God’s Word from others while claiming exemption from that same Word.

7. DOES RELIGIOUS SUCCESS PROVE THAT SOMEONE IS RIGHT WITH GOD?
Not necessarily.
A ministry may attract large crowds, receive substantial financial contributions or become widely known.
These achievements may indicate influence or organisational growth.
However, they are not automatic proof of spiritual faithfulness.
Matthew 7:22-23 records Jesus warning that extraordinary religious activities do not necessarily establish a genuine relationship with Him.
The decisive issue is not merely what someone appears to accomplish publicly.
It is whether that person’s life and ministry are consistent with the will of God.
Popularity is not the same as holiness. Religious influence is not the same as spiritual integrity.
This principle should encourage every ministry to value accountability, transparency and ethical leadership.

8. HOW SHOULD THE CHURCH RESPOND TO BELIEVERS WHO FALL INTO SIN?
The Church must balance truth with restoration.
Galatians 6:1 instructs spiritually mature believers to restore someone caught in wrongdoing with gentleness, while remaining watchful over themselves.
Matthew 18:15-17 provides principles for addressing wrongdoing within the community of believers.
These passages demonstrate that correction is part of Christian responsibility.
However, correction must not become humiliation, revenge or an excuse for abuse.
Where wrongdoing involves exploitation, violence or criminal conduct, appropriate safeguarding and lawful accountability are also necessary.
Forgiveness should not be used to conceal harm or deny justice to victims.
Biblical restoration requires truth, repentance, responsibility and genuine change-not merely a public apology followed by continued wrongdoing.

9. CAN A PERSON LOSE SALVATION THROUGH PERSISTENT REBELLION?
This question has been debated among Evangelical and Pentecostal Christians.
Some traditions teach that a genuinely regenerated believer will ultimately persevere in faith.
Others teach that a believer can turn away from Christ through persistent and deliberate apostasy.
Both positions seek to account for biblical passages concerning God’s preserving grace and warnings against falling away.
John 10:27-29 emphasises the security of Christ’s sheep.
Hebrews 3:12-14 warns believers against developing an unbelieving heart that turns away from the living God.
Hebrews 6:4-6 and Hebrews 10:26-29 contain solemn warnings that Christians must not dismiss.
Although Born-Again Christians differ on the precise theological explanation, there is broad agreement that deliberate, persistent rebellion must never be treated lightly.
We should therefore avoid offering false assurance to people who openly reject Christ’s authority while continuing to claim His name.
At the same time, we should encourage those who sincerely repent and seek God’s mercy.
The proper response to biblical warnings is not careless speculation about another person’s salvation, but sincere faith, repentance and perseverance in Christ.

10. WHY MUST CHRISTIANS EXAMINE THEMSELVES BEFORE CONDEMNING OTHERS?
Jesus warned against hypocrisy in Matthew 7:3-5.
He challenged those who noticed faults in others while ignoring serious wrongdoing in their own lives.
Second Corinthians 13:5 calls believers to examine themselves concerning their faith.
These passages are especially relevant to our discussion.
It would be inconsistent for Christians to condemn unbelievers for rebellion while excusing corruption, exploitation and deliberate wrongdoing within their own congregations.
If we proclaim that Jesus Christ is Lord, our lives should demonstrate submission to His authority.
The Church’s message about repentance becomes more credible when the Church itself practises repentance.
Our witness must begin with our own obedience.

11. HOW DOES THIS RELATE TO OUR ORIGINAL QUESTION?
Our original question asks whether refusing to accept Jesus Christ attracts divine punishment for rebellion.

Part Eight reminds us that rebellion cannot be understood merely as a label applied to people outside the Church.
Those who profess faith must also take God’s commands seriously.
The New Testament warns against both unbelief and hypocritical religious profession.
Therefore, the question is not simply whether someone publicly identifies as Born Again.
The deeper question concerns genuine faith in Christ and the transformation that follows.
We must not reduce salvation to a religious label, nor reduce rebellion to the absence of that label.
God calls all humanity to repentance, and He calls His people to live consistently with the faith they profess.

QUESTIONS FOR PERSONAL REFLECTION
1. Does my life increasingly reflect the teachings of Jesus Christ?
2. Have I confused religious participation with genuine spiritual transformation?
3. Do I use God’s grace as an excuse for wrongdoing?
4. When I fall into sin, am I willing to repent and accept correction?
5. Do I hold Christian leaders to the moral standards taught in Scripture?
6. Does my church practise accountability, transparency and responsible restoration?
7. Am I more concerned about condemning unbelievers than examining my own obedience to Christ?

CONCLUSION
From a Born-Again Christian understanding of Scripture, genuine salvation should produce a transformed relationship with God and a growing commitment to obedience.
Christians are not saved through moral perfection or religious performance.
They are saved by God’s grace through faith in Jesus Christ.
However, that grace must never be used to justify deliberate rebellion.
A Christian may struggle, fall and require restoration.
But persistent wrongdoing accompanied by a refusal to repent is a serious spiritual warning.
The same Gospel that calls unbelievers to receive Christ calls professing believers to examine their faith and conduct.
We cannot faithfully preach repentance to the world while refusing to practise repentance within the Church.
Our credibility as Born-Again Christians should not rest primarily upon religious titles, public declarations or the size of our congregations.
It should be reflected in lives marked by faith, humility, integrity, love and obedience to Jesus Christ.
The strongest evidence of a genuine Christian witness is not merely the ability to say, “I am Born Again,” but a life increasingly transformed by the grace and truth of Jesus Christ.

COMING NEXT – PART NINE: WHAT ABOUT PEOPLE WHO HAVE NEVER HEARD OR UNDERSTOOD THE GOSPEL?

In Part Nine, we shall examine the difficult question of those who have never had a meaningful opportunity to hear about Jesus Christ, and how God’s justice, human conscience and the responsibility of evangelism relate to their circumstances.
May God grant us humility, wisdom and the courage to examine our own lives in the light of His Word.
Rev. Dr. Samuel Elijah Kibirige
Christian Minister, Scholar and Author
Good Shepherd Community Ministries (GOSHEM)
Born-Again Christian Teaching Series – Part Eight