Inside the Labor Dispute ruling: How Centenary Bank lost a UGX 24.2M Case against former Employee Mukisa Daniel

Ad

In a significant legal defeat highlighting the imperative of fair hearing and verifiable evidence in industrial relations, Centenary Bank has been ordered to pay over 24.2 million Uganda Shillings (UGX 24,249,791) to its former employee, Mukisa Daniel. The ruling was delivered by Labour Officer Ms. Ruth Kulabako Namaarwa under Labour Complaint No. KCCA/CEN/LC/474 of 2025 at the Kampala Capital City Authority (KCCA) District Labour Office in Nakawa Division. The tribunal declared that Mukisa was unlawfully dismissed and denied a fair hearing after being falsely implicated in a high-tech corporate UGX 1.95 billion fraud conspiracy.

Background of the Dispute and allegations:

Mukisa Daniel entered employment with Centenary Bank as Loans Officer on October 16, 2018. His career took a drastic turn when the bank accused him of colluding with a co-worker, Gumisiriza Herbert, to smuggle and connect an unauthorized rogue device (Raspberry pi) into the Kawempe-Bwaise Branch Network for fraudulent purposes. Following these accusations, Mukisa was arrested and subsequently suspended on 9th, August 2024. He remained on extended suspension for over a year until 2nd September, 2025, when the bank summarily dismissed him while withholding his terminal benefits, prompting his formal complaint before the KCCA District Labour Office.

Centenary Bank strongly defended its position by asserting that Mukisa was dismissed through due process and had waived his right to be heard by failing to appear for scheduled disciplinary hearings. However, cross-examination of the bank’s own Witnesses fundamentally dismantled its case. The bank’s first witness, designated as RW1, testified that although he investigated the alleged fraud, he found no evidence establishing that Mukisa introduced the rogue device into the bank’s network system. Similarly, the second witness, investigator Mr. Moses Nsereko (RW2), admitted under oath that his investigation yielded no implicating evidence against Mukisa. Mr. Nsereko conceded that he neither interviewed Mukisa nor provided him with a copy of the Security and Investigations Department report, explaining that he withheld it specifically because it did not implicate him.

The institutional procedural flaws were further corroborated by Mrs. Nanyonjo Cecilia (RW3), who chaired the bank’s disciplinary committee. Mrs. Nanyonjo testified that Mukisa was never provided with copies of any of the three investigation reports relied upon by management to execute his dismissal. All respondent witnesses ultimately acknowledged under questioning that their belief in Mukisa’s guilt was premised entirely on the physical proximity of the rogue device to his workstation. However, testimony simultaneously established that the credit department section where Mukisa sat was a shared physical space utilized by several other staff members.

Rogue-Device-Detection-and-Mitigation

Legal analysis and substantive findings:

In her comprehensive evaluation, Labour Officer Mrs. Ruth Kulabako Namaarwa ruled that an employee’s statutory and constitutional right to a fair hearing couldn’t be realized when investigation reports containing the underlying allegations were concealed. Internal email correspondence entered into evidence revealed that Mukisa made multiple written requests for the investigation reports, details of the rogue device, and relevant CCTV footage. Although HR Business Partnering Manager Mrs. Basheija Brenda formally requested that this information be made available to the employee, bank official Edson Bwambale explicitly declined to fulfill the request. The Labour Officer further noted that the disciplinary committee compromised its impartiality by secretly receiving investigation reports from investigators without disclosing them to the accused employee, yet proceeding to dismiss him based on those concealed findings.

Substantive digital evidence further exonerated the former employee. Forensic reports submitted as exhibit REX3 demonstrated that Mukisa’s work computer contained no incriminating activity. Furthermore, technical network logs established that the rogue device was actively operating within the bank’s system on 6th, July 2024, and 31st, July 2024, well before 1st, August 2024, the date the bank alleged Mukisa introduced it. Additional forensic addendums (REX4) of 2025 confirmed that the bank’s technical investigation was still incomplete and anticipated further analysis to identify the actual perpetrators.

Reaffirming established legal precedents, including the Court of Appeal judgment in Uganda Breweries Limited v. Robert Kigula and Others, the Labour Officer emphasized that alleged employee misconduct must be verifiable and supported by concrete proof rather than mere suspicion. Because Centenary Bank failed to present verifiable evidence or call critical witnesses to substantiate the allegations, the tribunal held that the bank possessed no genuine factual basis to conclude that Mukisa was guilty of fraud or insubordination.

Concluding the matter in favor of Mukisa Daniel, the Labour Officer issued a series of statutory monetary awards totaling UGX 24,249,791. This sum comprises UGX 1,742,500 awarded under Section 65(4) of the Employment Act for failure to accord a fair hearing, UGX 12,052,291 as severance allowance for six years and eight months of continuous service under Sections 86 and 88 of the Act, and UGX 3,485,000 as two months’ pay in lieu of notice pursuant to Section 57(3)(c). The tribunal also awarded basic compensation of UGX 1,742,500 representing eight weeks’ wages under Section 77(1), additional compensation of UGX 5,227,500 representing three months’ salary for summary dismissal based on unproven fraud allegations, and Further instructed the Bank to release UGX 13,593,604 in accumulated terminal benefits under the staff contribution scheme. The bank was further directed to issue Mukisa a formal Certificate of Service within fourteen working days.

While the tribunal resolved all statutory employment claims, it noted that non-statutory claims fall outside the statutory scope of a District Labour Officer under Section 12 of the Employment Act. Consequently, Mukisa’s additional claims regarding the repayment of an outstanding salary loan, general damages, aggravated damages, and legal costs were formally referred to the Industrial Court of Uganda for final determination.

Our effort to reach the Bank Management for comment on this matter was futile since all our calls were not responded to.

Admissions Open 2026

G&E Sallim Christian High School

“God Is My Heritage”

Give your child a bright future. Enroll today for a quality, faith-based education.

+256 752 613162