Opinion

IS THE EU DELEGATION IN UGANDA PLAYING DOUBLE STANDARDS IN THEIR QUEST FOR ENVIRONMENTAL CONSERVATION?

I have noted with concern the remarks by the EU envoys to Uganda during their consultative meeting with Uganda’s legislators on the natural resources committee of Parliament on Monday, 26th October, 2020.
According to the New Vision of Wednesday 28th October, 2020, the EU delegation to Uganda has advised the government of Uganda to exploit all legal options to halt plans to use a section of Bugoma forest for sugarcane growing. “The Attorney General should be called in immediately for a full brief about the legal status and options available to save the forest. He should be able to come and take parliament through the legal options and maybe even file a restrain order” said the head of the EU delegation to Uganda Ambassador Attilio Pacifici. The diplomat’s advice was prompted by Kioga County MP Hon. Anthony Okello who sought the delegation’s input on how the government can quickly solve the impasse over Bugoma forest.

Ad

Ambassador Attilio Pacifici is also reported to have told the committee of parliament how they have documented satellite images captured by over 12 satellites from Europe that show how the destruction of Bugoma forest is getting bigger every single day. The EU diplomats also reportedly wondered how Uganda’s government agencies in connivance with individuals would collude to have a huge forest area cleared infavour of sugarcane growing. The delegation reportedly additionally implored parliament to use it’s oversight powers to investigate the actions of NEMA, Hoima sugar Ltd and the lands ministry for issuing land titles in forest reserves, approving ESIA reports and disregarding national laws and other illegal actions.

I must appreciate the EU delegation’s passion and concern towards protecting the environment in Uganda.
However, it would have been a good practice if the delegation sought to appreciate facts about the matter before sounding judgemental and outrightly biased. The EU delegation is rightly referring to Bugoma forest which is gazzeted as central forest reserve (CFR) and yet the land under contention which is described as plot 216 block 2 in Kyangwali is a privately owned land by Bunyoro kitara kingdom that lawfully leased it to the private investor Hoima sugar Ltd to grow sugarcane for sugar production and other related products. It’s adjacency to the Bugoma central forest reserve doesn’t make it part of the CFR and therefore it can’t be under the management of NFA unless the EU delegation wants to support an illegal and scandalous seizure of the kingdom land by NFA.
The ownership question for the said piece of land was resolved in favour of Bunyoro kitara kingdom by the High Court in Masindi in a case where NFA is challenging the ownership. On the 25th April, 2019 Justice Wilson Musalu Musene dismissed the case with costs. In his judgement, the judge ruled that Bunyoro kitara kingdom duly acquired the freehold interest and legally leased the said land to Hoima sugar Ltd.


NFA dissatisfied with the ruling, appealed and the matter is yet to be disposed of by the court of Appeal pending the main hearing. NFA applied for the stay of execution of the High Court ruling in the Court of Appeal and it was dismissed by Justice Fredrick Egonda Ntende on December 3, 2019. In his ruling, the judge emphasized the need for the investor to seek clearance from the environment regulatory body NEMA to conduct an ESIA.
On the 14th August, 2020, Hoima sugar Ltd was issued with a certificate of clearance after successfully conducting an ESIA where out of the 21.54 square miles of the land it leased from Bunyoro kitara kingdom, it was conditioned to use only 9.24 square miles for growing sugarcane which is less than half of the total area of the land that was acquired for the same purpose. Hoima sugar Ltd was also tasked by NEMA to develop an urban center on 1.26 square miles, establish an ecotourism center on 1.97 square miles, restore 3.13 square miles of the forest to act as a buffer between the sugarcane plantation and the Bugoma CRF, preserve 0.156 hectares for the cultural site and conserve 6.17 square miles as a natural forest.

True Uganda is signatory to a number of international treaties and conventions on environmental conservation and protection but these treaties can’t be operationalized in isolation of the national laws and policies on environment and land use and this is a fact that must be appreciated by both the local and International environmental conservation enthusiasts and/ or activists.
The EU delegation needed to seek guidance on the above facts before committing the contempt of court. The delegation by choosing to comment on the matter that’s before court they overlooked the rule of sub judice something that must be a huge concern to a high profile International delegation of EU’s stature. The EU delegation acted on the assumption that the said land is under Bugoma CFR and it’s therefore under the management of NFA which assumption is both innacurate and misleading.
The EU rightly implores the government to explore all legal options to save Bugoma forest and this is exactly what government of Uganda is doing. By NFA going to court and loosing the case in favour of Bunyoro kingdom and Hoima sugar Ltd, by NEMA performing it’s regulatory role and forcing Hoima sugar Ltd to adjust in its earlier investment plans, it means the government is not top of the game. It confirms that Uganda has got both independent and interdependent functional systems. Does the EU delegation want the government of Uganda to bend the laws and favour an illegality?
Uganda’s cabinet took a decision to fast track the opening of the boundaries of Bugoma CFR through the line ministries of Lands, Water and Environment to ascertain the actual boundaries to resolve the ownership question. On Wednesday 28th October, 2020, both NFA, Hoima sugar Ltd and Bunyoro Kitara kingdom made a physical inspection of Bugoma forest to pick the coordinates in support of the cabinet decision to open the boundaries. Soon or later this ownership question shall be put to rest and that’s why in a situation like this one, it’s highly advisable for a reputable high profile International delegation of EU stature not to rush into making conclusions prematurely.


It’s absolutely true that the actual Bugoma CFR is under serious threat by illegal loggers under a watchful eye of the NFA that’s an institution mandated to protect gazzeted forests in Uganda. This ugly trend is being facilitated by the corruption among the lower and top ranks within NFA and it’s not true that the destruction of Bugoma forest has started with the coming of Hoima sugar Ltd which is purely doing its operations outside the gazzeted forest land.
The REUTERS a popular news agency in Europe carried a screaming headline on the 21st February, 2020 thus, “Tesla gets Germany approval to destroy forest for Giga factory in Berlin”. The US electric carmaker last November said it would build a factory in Gruenheide in the Eastern state of Brandenburg near Berlin, creating up to 12000 jobs a decision that was initially lauded as a vote of confidence in Germany. Tesla wants to start production in 2021 but environmentalists exploited legal loopholes in the planning process to halt felling of trees until an environmental audit is finalized to gauge whether any rare species could be endangered.


Activists from a group calling themselves the “Tree pirates” with the motto “up with trees, down with capitalism” said it had occupied the forest to prevent Tesla from building its plant.
A local court had a day before stepped in and rejected environmentalists’ efforts to stop the land from being cleared of trees, adding that it’s ruling is final and therefore could not be appealed. The courts decision according to the REUTERS was welcomed the following day by the Germany’s industry association BDI and economy minister Peter Altmaier. “It’s an important signal” Altmaier is quoted to have said on the sidelines of an event in Lithuania. Law makers from Germany’s pro-business Christian Democrat and Free Democrat parties had warned that the legal battle waged against the Giga factory would inflict serious damage on Germany’s image as a place to do business.
Now here is the irony, the trend in Europe about economic development vs environmental conservation with the recent developments in Germany which is part of the European Union clearly exposes the double standardness and/ or hypocrisy of the Excellencies European diplomats to Uganda. As they are busy joining the forces to frustrate investment in the third world countries, back home they are part of governments which are boldly pushing for the forest destruction in favour of industrialization while advancing the same reasons such as job creation and expansion of economy to widen their tax base.
Moreover in Germany the pleas by the environmental activists landed on government deaf ears and even court quashed their prayers with no room for appealing. For the case of Hoima sugar Ltd, the land under contention is purely a private property not gazzeted as a CFR but rather just mistaken for one and courts of law have proved that. Even the room for an appeal was allowed to be advanced by NFA and environmental activists. Court is doing its job as mandated by the law and making rulings accordingly.
Surprisingly, the EU delegation to Uganda finds it convenient to interfere with the affairs on a privately owned piece of land adjacent to Bugoma CFR and yet their governments are busy going after the gazzeted public forests to pave way for economic development. What a contradiction!
The author is Amlan Tumusiime NRM mobilizer Bunyoro region

To  find back up information check these news link; https://www.reuters.com/article/us-tesla-gigafactory-germany-cutting-idUSKBN20F1SK

https://www.dailysabah.com/automotive/2020/02/21/tesla-gets-german-approval-to-destroy-forest-for-gigafactory-in-berlin and above are related photos in Amlans’s opinion of how Germany’s trees were being cut down to give way to development and a factory.

 

Admissions Open 2026

G&E Sallim Christian High School

“God Is My Heritage”

Give your child a bright future. Enroll today for a quality, faith-based education.

+256 752 613162