KAMPALA – Last week, the Electoral Commission (EC) ejected Mathias Walukaga from the Busiro East parliamentary race. It argued that the academic document relied on for his nomination did not meet the minimum academic qualification set out under Section 4 (1)(c) of the Parliamentary Elections Act (PEA) having been expired before nomination day.
The queried academic document was a Mature Age Entry Certificate (MAEC) obtained from the Islamic University in Uganda and dully equated by the National Council for Higher Education (NCHE). By and large, the EC’s main argument was that by the time these documents were submitted for certification and later to the EC for nomination, the same had long expired on 23rd June, 2025 and could not be given a new lease of life by NCHE.
I need to remind my readers that Mature Age Entry is an accepted pathway for persons above 25years to access university education. The system essentially bypasses the traditional A-Level requirements by taking special exams allowing the person to pursue degrees, and effectively equating their mature age entry certificate to an A-Level qualification.
Thus, a MAEC as opposed to a degree is what is treated as equivalent to A-Level (Senior Six) and is one of the alternative entry qualifications for university admission. The certificate is however valid for two years from the date of issue and requires passing specific NCHE-approved exams (50% of the aptitude/general knowledge) as provided for under Para 9(b) of the Universities and Other Tertiary Institutions Legal Notice No. 12 of 2015.
In their wisdom and having nominated Walukaga using the NCHE documents, the commission reversed its own decision saying the candidate did not meet the minimum academic formal qualifications required of a Member of Parliament in total disregard to the guidance of NCHE which had equated the results as being equivalent to advanced level.

My interpretation is that the Mature Age Entry Certificate only becomes stale if it is not used to join university within a period of two years. We are told that having obtained the MAEC, Walukaga immediately applied and was admitted as a student at St Lawerence University within the prescribed two years grace period inscribed on the Certificate.
If it is true that Walukaga complied with the two-year condition, it goes without saying that his Mature Age Entry Certificate remained valid to date and can be used at any time as a minimum qualification to contest as a Member of Parliament. After all, the same had been verified and confirmed by the National Council for Higher Education.

Please note that the EC did not say a MAEC cannot be used as an equivalent of A-levels certificate but it said the act of NCHE in equating an expired certificate was irregular and could not revive an expired document. The only question now that stands before court is whether or not the MAEC was expired and therefore could not be used for Walukaga’s nomination.
Before becoming the Electoral Commission Chairman in 2016, Simon Byabakama was serving as a justice of the Court of Appeal, having been appointed by President Museveni in October 2015 after his long career in the Directorate of Public Prosecutions. He now finds himself placed between a rock and a hard place; his unfortunate decision will now be scrutinized by a junior member of the bench at the level of a High court Judge.
The High Court’s investigation will be confined within the boundaries of ascertaining whether the National Council acted ultra vires and whether in exercising its discretionary power it acted corruptly or in bad faith or whether the Council considered alien and irrelevant matters, in which case the National Council’s act would be a nullity.”
But how did we get here. We all know that District registrars are employees of the Electoral commission and thus their actions or inactions fall squarely on their employer. In the absence of an established tribunal to handle post nomination complaints on behalf of the EC, the commission itself is not the most competition entity to handle or even determine the complaints as it is potential respondent in the same dispute.
How can the same Electoral commission which nominated Walukaga turn around and be a judge in its own cause? I am mindful of Section 15 of the Electoral commission Act which allows the commission to rectify its own mistakes but must not do so as if they were a competent court because they are not and are glaringly conflicted.
That explains why the commission’s decision confirming or rejecting an irregularity (like it is in the Walukaga case) is not subjected to a judicial review but an appeal to the high court. By asking an aggrieved person to seek redress from the offender is self-defeating and certainly offends the well-entrenched principles of natural justice.
Even if the commission had the powers to entertain the complaints, they ought to do so aware that the process can be abused by self-seekers. Besides, what would the commission do if none of its members was a Judge as was the case during the tenure of Badru Kigundu? Is this commission even aware that an aggrieved party not willing to appeal can claim a refund of nomination fees and all the costs incidental thereto under Section 15(1) of the Act?
The decision of the EC not only punches holes in the institution of IUIU as far as MAEC is concerned but also undermines the NCHE as an institution almost declaring it incompetent for having equated a MAEC that was already expired in June, 2025. The decision also declares the EC Registrar at Wakiso as being unfit for his office and perhaps should be fired.
A few years ago, the EC used to have what it called “pre nomination certificates where they would do a background check on candidates who had expressed interest in contesting for political office, this was stopped for unknown reasons. These days, the EC only learns of hidden irregularities way after a candidate has been nominated and allowed to start campaign.
It is hardly 28 days to polling day but the EC is still dilly darling with some unresolved disputes to date. The delay to deliver their verdict subject the candidates to emotional torture and denies them a chance to remain in the field not knowing whether or not the outcome will be in their favour or not. This is not acceptable.
Matters are made worse that Section 15 of the Electoral Commission Act gives the commission an open cheque to the extent that they do not have timelines within which they are supposed to determine petitions filed before them. They can even wait until the eve of the election to eject somebody who has no chance of running to the High Court to challenge their decision.
This impugned law allowing the EC to review complaint submitted at any time and at any stage is occasioning an injustice and must be amended and in the alternative, the EC must immediately institute an independent tribunal to handle such disputes. For now, the EC acts as the judge and also at the same time as a prosecutor despite being a potential respondent.
The above opinion was written by Wadada Rogers.
He is a commentator on political, legal and social issues. wadroger@yahoo.ca
